Planning a trip to the Buffalo area? The Wyndham Garden Hotel in Amherst, NY, is a popular choice for both business and leisure travelers. Located just off the I-290, it offers easy access to downtown Buffalo, the University at Buffalo, and Niagara Falls. But is it the right hotel for you? In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know—from room features and amenities to common pitfalls and money-saving tips. Whether you're visiting for a conference, a family vacation, or a quick getaway, this review will help you decide.
Location and Accessibility
The Wyndham Garden Hotel Amherst is situated at 3750 Maple Road, Amherst, NY, right near the intersection of I-290 and Maple Road. This location is a major plus. You’re about 15 minutes from Buffalo Niagara International Airport, 20 minutes from downtown Buffalo, and 30 minutes from Niagara Falls. The hotel is also adjacent to the Boulevard Mall and several restaurants, making it convenient for grabbing a bite or shopping. If you’re visiting the University at Buffalo’s North Campus, it’s only a 5-minute drive. For business travelers, the hotel is close to corporate offices in the Amherst and Williamsville areas.
Room Options and Amenities
The hotel offers standard rooms, suites, and accessible rooms. All rooms come with a microwave, mini-fridge, coffee maker, flat-screen TV, and free Wi-Fi. Beds are comfortable with plush pillows, but some guests note that the mattresses can be a bit firm. Suites include a separate living area with a sofa bed, which is great for families. The on-site fitness center is small but has cardio machines and free weights. The indoor pool and hot tub are clean and well-maintained—perfect for unwinding after a day of sightseeing. One standout amenity is the complimentary hot breakfast, which includes eggs, sausage, waffles, and fresh fruit. However, the breakfast area can get crowded during peak hours (7:30–9 AM), so plan accordingly.
Common Guest Issues and How to Avoid Them
While most stays are positive, some guests report issues like noisy air conditioning units, inconsistent housekeeping, and occasional maintenance problems. To avoid these:
Request a room away from the elevator and ice machines—these areas can be noisy.
Check the AC/Heater immediately upon check-in; if it’s loud or not working, ask for a room change.
For housekeeping, if you need fresh towels or linens, call the front desk; they are usually responsive.
Parking is free and ample, but spots near the entrance fill up fast; you can park further and walk. Also, note that the hotel does not have an on-site restaurant for dinner, but there are delivery options (like pizza and Chinese) within walking distance.
Tips for Getting the Best Rate
Prices at the Wyndham Garden Amherst vary by season and demand. To get the best deal:
Book directly on the Wyndham website—they often have member-only rates and cancellation flexibility.
Check for AAA, AARP, or military discounts at check-in.
Avoid booking during University of Buffalo graduation weekends or major events (like the National Buffalo Wing Festival) when rates spike.
Use a rewards credit card that offers bonus points for hotel stays.
Consider a suite if traveling with family—the extra space is worth the small price difference.
Read cancellation policies carefully; some third-party bookings are non-refundable.
Nearby Attractions and Dining
Beyond the hotel, there’s plenty to do. The Niagara Falls State Park is a 30-minute drive—don’t miss the Maid of the Mist boat tour. Closer to the hotel, you can explore the Buffalo Zoo (15 minutes) or the Albright-Knox Art Gallery (20 minutes). For food, the hotel is near several chain restaurants (Applebee’s, Olive Garden) but also local gems like The Cheesecake Factory and Anchor Bar (the original buffalo wing spot) is a 15-minute drive. If you prefer delivery, Uber Eats and DoorDash are available. For grocery needs, a Walmart Supercenter is just 5 minutes away.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does the hotel have a shuttle to the airport?
A: No, but the hotel can arrange a taxi or rideshare. The airport is only 15 minutes away, so Uber/Lyft cost around $15–20.
Q: Is the hotel pet-friendly?
A: No, pets are not allowed except for service animals.
Q: Is breakfast included in the room rate?
A: Yes, the hot breakfast is complimentary for all guests.
Q: What time is check-in and check-out?
A: Check-in is at 3 PM, check-out at 11 AM. Early check-in/late check-out may be available upon request.
Q: Is there a fee for parking?
A: No, parking is free.
Final Verdict
The Wyndham Garden Hotel Amherst offers solid value for travelers who prioritize location and basic amenities. While it’s not a luxury property, the clean rooms, free breakfast, and convenient access to Buffalo and Niagara Falls make it a reliable choice. By following the tips above—like requesting a quiet room and booking directly—you can avoid common issues and have a comfortable stay. For the price, it’s hard to beat, especially if you’re on a budget or need a home base for exploring the area.